KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

beardyman
Topic Author
Offline

30 Sep 2015 18:29 #38283 by beardyman

KN protocol broken in latest nightly? was created by beardyman

I just updated from v4.0.1-c3007aa to the very latest nightly, v4.0.1-a5a424c, and I am no longer able to bind my v931 to my Devo 7e. My Devo 10, which I haven't updated yet, still binds perfectly. Did something break in the KN protocol?

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

beardyman
Topic Author
Offline

30 Sep 2015 19:14 #38286 by beardyman

Replied by beardyman on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

It seems to relate to the initialisation of the nrf24l01, because after selecting my v931 model file I am unable to bind to my Hisky helicopters without power cycling the transmitter.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moeder
Offline

30 Sep 2015 22:55 #38295 by Moeder

Replied by Moeder on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

Did you try pressing bind twice? I've had some issues with it not binding on the first try due to some currently unknown issue.
Also, please go into protocol options and check that Format Wl Toys is selected.
Finally, try selecting 11 channels for your model setup, as the updated protocol also implements trim channels.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

beardyman
Topic Author
Offline

30 Sep 2015 23:24 #38298 by beardyman

Replied by beardyman on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

Thanks for your reply. I have indeed tried pressing bind twice, and I have WLToys selected in protocol options, and 11 channels selected. But I still can't bind!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moeder
Offline

01 Oct 2015 15:29 #38316 by Moeder

Replied by Moeder on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

What modules do you have installed in your 7E?

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

beardyman
Topic Author
Offline

01 Oct 2015 16:16 #38317 by beardyman

Replied by beardyman on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

I have multimodule installed, with a7105, nrf24l01 and cc2500. And the same in my Devo 10, which does work!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moeder
Offline

03 Oct 2015 20:10 #38399 by Moeder

Replied by Moeder on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

You are the first one I hear using KN with a multi module. Maybe you're right and it has something to do with the module initialization. I will try to make a build using the current protocol but with the old initialization code and post it in this thread. But since I'm quite busy this week it may take a couple of days for me to find some spare time.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

beardyman
Topic Author
Offline

03 Oct 2015 20:29 #38402 by beardyman

Replied by beardyman on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

Thanks so much for your help with this, and also for your work on the protocol. I can still fly the v931 with my Devo 10, which I will hold off from updating until the problem is resolved, so no need to rush if you're busy!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

davidwyl
Offline

11 Oct 2015 12:01 - 11 Oct 2015 12:13 #38732 by davidwyl

Replied by davidwyl on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

tried nightly 2015-10-01 deviation-devo10-v4.0.1-2cde795 and 2015-10-10 deviation-devo12-v4.0.1-9dc1d32 but i cant bind it to v977 (KN Protocol) anything i did wrong?
im using deo 7e with multimodule 1.3 installed.

Last edit: 11 Oct 2015 12:13 by davidwyl.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

beardyman
Topic Author
Offline

11 Oct 2015 15:49 #38742 by beardyman

Replied by beardyman on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

You're not doing anything wrong - it's still broken for me too. It seems to be related to our both using the multi-module. v4.0.1-c3007aa is still available, and this was working on my Devo 7E, and continues to work on my Devo 10.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moeder
Offline

11 Oct 2015 21:09 #38747 by Moeder

Replied by Moeder on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

Haven't gotten to fixing it yet, but since it seems related to the multimodule now it should only be a matter of adjusting the initialization. It's on my agenda for this week, so hang in there

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moeder
Offline

12 Oct 2015 19:54 #38765 by Moeder

Replied by Moeder on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

Please try the build attached, whenever you have time. It has updated initialization code and is based on the current nightly.

P.S.: Don't worry too much about the timestamps of the file, I compiled them on a virtual machine which doesn't care too much about updating it's time when waking up from a saved state

P.P.S: Attachment limit on this board sucks....so here is a link:
drive.google.com/file/d/0B8dJnjyIoiwobjJ...bTQ/view?usp=sharing

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

beardyman
Topic Author
Offline

12 Oct 2015 21:08 #38766 by beardyman

Replied by beardyman on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

Many thanks for that, but sadly still not working for me!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moeder
Offline

19 Oct 2015 07:24 #39040 by Moeder

Replied by Moeder on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

Are you sure you updated DFU, protocol and also installed the latest filesystem? Please check again, if nothing works I'll dig some more in the code...
Other models with the NRF module are running flawless?

beardyman wrote: Many thanks for that, but sadly still not working for me!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

beardyman
Topic Author
Offline

19 Oct 2015 21:06 #39056 by beardyman

Replied by beardyman on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

I initially installed all the files you uploaded, including the dfu, over v4.0.1-a5a424c. To double check I've installed the latest nightly, v4.0.1-9cce188, and installed your files on top, but I still can't get it to work. I'm using a fixed txid so I can use either my Devo 7e or my Devo 10, so I shouldn't need to bind, but nevertheless I have tried everything I can think of to bind without success. My Devo 10 still works perfectly on v4.0.1-c3007aa.

Having reinstalled everything, I'm pretty sure I haven't made a mistake and that it just doesn't work! I'd be happy to be proved wrong, but I'm pretty certain now!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

beardyman
Topic Author
Offline

21 Oct 2015 18:53 #39105 by beardyman

Replied by beardyman on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

Other NRF protocols are working fine - I've tried Hisky, v262 and CX-10.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moeder
Offline

08 Nov 2015 20:30 #39755 by Moeder

Replied by Moeder on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

Sorry it took a while...I found some more differences in the initialization, please try the following builds:

Devo 7e
Devo 10

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

beardyman
Topic Author
Offline

09 Nov 2015 17:07 #39780 by beardyman

Replied by beardyman on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

Many thanks for that! I can confirm that I'm now able to bind to my v931 with both my Devo 7e and 10. And as far as I can tell, everything seems to be working correctly!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moeder
Offline

09 Nov 2015 18:45 #39781 by Moeder

Replied by Moeder on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

Fantastic. In the end it seems that just a single line was missing. Would you mind testing another build for me after I cleaned up the code a little bit? If that works I will make a pull request for the Bugfix so it will appear in future nightlies.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

beardyman
Topic Author
Offline

09 Nov 2015 19:08 #39782 by beardyman

Replied by beardyman on topic KN protocol broken in latest nightly?

Of course I will be more than happy to test another build. After all, you're the one doing all the hard work!

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Time to create page: 0.053 seconds

Force desktop display